The worst of non-Muslims convert to Islam, the best of Muslims leave Islam. Part 2
This is the problem with 'reverts'. They lack the hardwiring that makes Muslims Muslim. Things that a raised Muslim would be incapable of thinking, a reverts is able to shout from the rooftops. In taking in Western academics in its scramble for Western converts, Islam has ingested a poison capsule.
Special Series on Apostasy: There's no better time than Ramadan
Not all converts to Islam are deluded, ignorant, or troubled souls that have hit rock bottom in their lives. Some are downright evil, such as Andrew Tate mentioned in Part 1, and find themselves drawn to the unbridled sadistic power that Islam affords to males over women (and over all living things, divinely so ordained): "Men are in charge of women, because Allah hath made the one of them to excel the other," entitling him to "beat them" (Qur'an 4:34). Shari'a makes it practically impossible for anyone to gain legal redress against a Muslim male who has wronged them, unless they are themselves Muslim. Male prerogative and impunity over women, slaves, children, dhimmis, animals and apostates are particularly egregious, worsening in that order. Iranian dissident Mansour Hekmat offers this glimpse: "In Islam, the woman is a slave. In Islam, the child is on par with animals." V S Naipaul, in his Beyond Belief: Islamic excursions among the converted peoples, describes the divine outcome of this arrangement in Pakistan:
So the women who had come to see the pir [saint] that day had to wait, and they were squatting like chickens in his courtyard in the sun. They were peasant women, serf women, chattel of their landlords and their husbands, unprotected by law, custom or religion. They lived with cruelty and their minds had half gone.
This edifice of horror is built upon Shari'a, a barbaric, extremely cruel and intensely misogynistic legal system specifically designed to secure a life of savage pleasures for the male who cares to join up, and an Afterlife abounding with the same. It is also how Islam's most illustrious convert came unstuck and ended up having to face an inquisition. It is a story that bears recounting at length.
The "revert" in question was American professor Dr Jonathan Brown, who did his PhD on the hadith and Shari'a. Clearly, Dr Brown's signing up to barbarism is not down to simple naïvety. There are no details that were concealed from him. He is well beyond what Sheikh Dr Yasir Qadhi would describe as "an advanced-advanced student of knowledge", i.e., someone well-versed in the darkest secrets of Islam that it is "not wise" for lay Muslims to be privy to. No sheikh duped Dr Brown, then an undergraduate, into saying the shahada. He did it in full knowledge of what he was doing. It takes a very special kind of evil to do something like that not only to yourself, but to your children and to the society that nurtured you in freedom and gave you the education that you now wield against it.
As if Shari'a is not grotesque enough and Muslims are not adept enough at imposing it on others, Dr Brown puts at the disposal of his adopted faith his unique selling point: the combination of an acute legal mind; complete commitment to Islam; superior knowledge of the inner workings of the West; especially the United States; and lacking the mind-crippling effects of a Muslim upbringing. This combination places Dr Brown in the near-unique position of being able to out-Muslim Muslims, a quality not always appreciated by his adoptive brethren.
In February 2020, eight months before a Muslim beheaded French schoolteacher Samuel Paty, Dr Brown pronounced to a stunned Muslim audience, “I fully support the right of people to actually insult the prophet in the United States, because I think that’s the best regime for human happiness.” Dr Brown, being an expert on Shari'a, had to have known that insulting the prophet is a crime punishable by death, so grave that it can neither be mitigated nor commuted. "Repentance is not accepted from him," who insults Muhammad. Dr Brown's intellectual vanity precluded him from appreciating just how profoundly offensive his pronouncement would be to his fellow Muslims.
Muslims are raised from a very young age to supplicate at the mere mention of Muhammad's name, always and without fail: peace be upon him. They say it automatically, even unconsciously. It is muscle memory. Their own failure to say it disturbs them at a very deep level. And before this proud, respectful audience, there to hear their most esteemed validator, their most high-profile “revert”, Dr Brown urged them to insult Muhammad, exactly what Muslims massacred the staff of Charlie Hebdo for doing. His hosts immediately intervened to nip the sudden fiasco in the bud, having to work hard to shield both Dr Brown from the ummah and the ummah from Dr Brown, at the same time taking care to shield his esteem, while also not belittling the sensibilities of their audience.
Raised in freedom, Dr Brown lacks the architecture of submission. His intellectual vanity drove him to lecture Muslims, while realpolitik drove him to defer to his hosts. He floundered, unable to reconcile his inner conflict. But Dr Jonathan Brown is too valuable to the beleaguered ummah for summary execution. Imagine what your prize revert's head rolling before a packed auditorium will do for the world's fastest-growing religion. It was going to take quite a bit of Shari'a acrobatics to keep Dr Brown's head attached to his shoulders. The Muslims decided on a reasonable compromise: an inquisition.
And who better Inquisitor to judge Professor Jonathan Brown, than the common da'wah street thug, Mohamed Hijab. Yet the sinner did not bow in abject gratitude at the favour to be interrogated. Instead, this was a peculiar mea culpa in which the heretic presumed to offer the Inquisitor a piece of strategic advice:
I do not think that Muslims should advocate laws that restrict speech …because the first people who will be restricted in their speech …will be Muslims. [If hate speech becomes illegal, then] the Qur’an itself becomes an article of hate speech.
This is the problem with 'reverts'. They lack the hardwiring that makes Muslims Muslim. Things that a raised Muslim is unable to think, a revert shouts from the rooftops. In taking in Western academics in its scramble for Western converts, Islam has ingested a poison capsule. Dr Jonathan Brown could be an Islamic psych-ops wunderkind, the American equivalent of Sheikh Mohammed al-Issa, Secretary General of the Muslim World League, if he could just get through to this myopic brute taking his confession, or in a wider context, circumvent the Muslim upbringing.
Jonathan Brown is saying to Muslims, play the Enlightenment system, let Muhammad take the hit, and you can without hindrance continue indoctrinating your children with Islam and teaching them the Qur’an. He is right, of course, but obviously fails to appreciate what Muhammad means to people damaged by a Muslim upbringing, particularly a madrassa childhood: Muhammad is Allah. In fact, should Dr Brown put his own children through madrassa mind-warping, they could eventually come for him as one who advised insulting their beloved prophet. Besides, only Allah can advise on happiness, and he has already set aside the Afterlife as the only happiness. “I fully support the right of people to actually insult the prophet in the United States, because I think that’s the best regime for human happiness.” Blasphemy, to boot. This is the problem with reverts, they might know Islam, but they have no idea how to be Muslim.
Inquisitor Mohammed Hijab, true to form, was having none of Dr Brown’s brilliant advice, insisting that the Shari’a was clear on such things. Islam indulges no quid pro quo with kufr. It offers neither equality nor reciprocity; Islam does not negotiate, it dominates. Islam alone decides who may and who may not say what. When Muslims promise career politicians that they will deliver the “Muslim vote”—what a curious notion—it is only because that politician is the conduit through which Muslims will embed their Shari’a demands in the democratic body politic and hollow it out from the inside. Concepts such as parity, equality, fairness, agreement, balance, non-discrimination, etc., are all alien to Islam; that is what domination means.
Dr Jonathan Brown giving a grovelling account of himself before a notorious Muslim da’wah bruiser was a sight to behold. Mohammed Hijab is a British wannabe academic who would hardly qualify to enrol onto any of Dr Brown’s most elementary classes. Dr Brown's humiliation was an unedifying spectacle. How those who grow up under Islam have to sacrifice to gain their dignity, their freedom, and a decent education. Yet, here this pampered clown from the freest and richest society in history was throwing it all away for the privilege of submitting to a brutish enforcer of barbarian law.
Dr Brown knows the kafir presumptions better than his new masters do, and is better able to achieve Islam’s monstrous ends without resorting to the brutish impulses of Muslims. The same fallacious presumptions underlie, for example, Western notions of persuading Muslims that they should reform Islam, or rallying behind those who style themselves Islamic reformers. To most Muslims, and certainly to Islam itself, such presumptions are an affront. It is extremely inappropriate for a kafir to presume reciprocity from a supremacist on whose sufferance he lives. An analogy would be a slave saying to his master, “OK, master. Here’s the deal…” That is what Brown’s advice about the benefits of insulting Muhammad sounds like to Muslim ears. The same goes for non-Muslims presuming to propose "interfaith dialogue" to Muslims. It is absurd.
Dr Brown is fully aware that he has signed up for supremacism and is unlikely to be unaware of the barbarism that white supremacism perpetrated on his black compatriots a mere hundred years ago. The Western “revert-Muslim” academic who does not immediately adopt supremacism still has some way to go before being accepted as properly Muslim. Jonathan Brown’s unbridled sophistry is quite safe from his Muslim audiences, who would not know what constitutes an argument in the first place, let alone distinguish a good argument from a bad one.
It becomes a matter of how long the Mohammed Hijabs of this world will put up with all the presumptuous coaching. Dr Brown sees his role as that of taking Muslim supremacism to the next level, through da'wah 2.0, and putting the inculcation of hatred into children onto a more sophisticated footing. He advises his adopted co-religionists to tolerate the lesser evil of insulting the prophet, to gain the greater good of freely spreading Qur’anic hatred through Western madrassas. Dr Brown is blissfully unaware that in a different place, this is the point at which a blade would be making its way through his neck.
Part 3/...
Picture credit:
Screen shot from "Controversial Questions to Prof.Jonathan Brown and Dr. Shadee ElMasri (MH Podcast #6), Mohammed Hijab, YouTube, 6 Jul 2020. https://youtu.be/7jXye1-Wbug